2010 Hospitality Report
We just added a PDF version of the CIASF’s 2010 Hospitality Report compiled by Guy Trusty to our CIASF page. Check it out.
We just added a PDF version of the CIASF’s 2010 Hospitality Report compiled by Guy Trusty to our CIASF page. Check it out.
For those of us involved in real estate for over 20 years, we have experienced cycles which seldom took more than 3-4 years to work out. This one is much different with few experts able to forecast a time to return to normalcy. It has been much more personal than the past because all of us have heard of the economic impacts on members of our families, neighbors and close friends. Those involved in real estate seem to be particularly hard hit. Architects, title insurance firms, engineers and developers have suffered mortal blows. It is understandable why the government administration grasps at green shoots in order to show improvement with our dire economy. Let’s dissect some of the most influential elements:
Here in Florida we have historically depended upon increasing population to feed our growth and real estate activity. That in turn fuels our construction employment. This growth has not occurred for the past two years and this year will show more outflow than inflow. This is causing havoc with local government budgets.
With our housing bubble resulting in serious overbuilding for single family and condos, we are still wallowing around trying to figure out when residential housing will return to normalcy. No question that bargain basement prices are assisting the sale of houses. But, this is with unusual amounts of government support such as the $8,000 credit for new home buyers and the fact that 90% of the residential financing has government backing. What will happen without this government support?
The unemployment numbers are downright scary. The present average unemployment level and length of time unemployed is the greatest since 1948. Paul Krugman, economist and writer for New York Times, says US household’s net worth has declined by $14 trillion. A large segment of our population, fearful of our burgeoning debt and feeling the need to increase reserves, is saving more and curtailing their consumer spending. Of course, this adversely impacts real estate investments.
We have yet to feel the full sledge hammer impact of commercial foreclosures, the result of commercial real estate having a 35-40 % reduction in market value. Locally and in the rest of Florida, we have a large amount of our commercial loans coming due in 5-10 years posing a tremendous challenge to both borrowers and lenders.
No rational answers have been forthcoming for these challenging elements. Against the backdrop of these daunting challenges giving advice to active investors is difficult. There will be a large group of investors who have been active in the area for years, throwing up their hands and electing not to play the game. Offsetting this will be some new players, bringing to the market large chunks of cash, attracted to buying well below replacement costs.
The great investor, Warren Buffett has several observations to remember:
“A simple rule dictates my buying: Be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy when others are fearful. And most certainly, fear is now widespread, gripping even seasoned investors.”
And “In short, bad news is an investor’s best friend. It lets you buy a slice of America’s future at a marked-down price.”
By: Gary Sisler
Last week Andrew and I presented the 2010 Miami-Dade County Industrial Market Study to over 240 members of the Commercial Industrial Association of South Florida. This is 15th year we have reported on the industrial market conditions in South Florida.
The Market Trends Section reported a growth in industrial space for the year of 2008 of just over 267,000 SF a decline of about 87% from the prior year. This downward trend was also evident in the industrial employment sector showing an employment decline of 7,600 to a total employment of just over 175,000. For the year of 2009 projected total freight at the Port of Miami declined by 8% while freight through Miami International Airport declined by 20%.
The Market Activity Section shows volume of warehouse sales remained the same at 74 buildings but a decline in the average sale price from $71/SF to $69/SF. The dollar amount of the sales decreased by 55% to $108,328,400. The industrial condominium market also slowed with a 25% decline in sales volume in 2009 and an average price decline from $144/SF to $122/SF.
Because of the variety of warehouse/industrial properties in various locations Miami-Dade County is divided into seven regions based on similar types of properties in each region. All regions are reporting an increase in the amount of rental space available, vacancy rates are as high as 18%-20% and rental rates have declined to as low as $3.50/SF in some areas.
Summary:
First year rental rates have declined from the mid $7.00/SF to as low as $3.50/SF. Some industrial property owners in larger buildings are renting for $1.00/SF plus all expenses (NNN) for the first year of a three year lease. Existing tenants are requesting rent rate reductions, abatement of rent or other concessions in exchange for longer term leases. Property managers are reviewing these requests on a case by case basis.
Vacancy rates should continue to increase from 13% and could rise to as high as 18% as a result of no new companies moving into this market. Existing companies are relocating from older less efficient buildings to newer buildings taking advantage of the lower rental rates in newer building with better access, parking and loading areas. This is forcing properties with functional problems to become even more rate competitive.
The major issues facing commercial property owners are the burden of additional governmental regulation and enforcement. Property owners are being forced to install expensive wired fire alarm systems, re-inspection for code compliance whenever a tenant applies for an occupational license.
The encouraging news in cargo compared to other US Customs districts is that Miami’s decline of 15% in trade from June 2008 to June 2009 was the smallest of all districts except Norfork/Mobile/Charleston. With the construction of two cargo facilities, the Miami International Airport will have an additional 800,000 SF of cargo space plus a new fumigation facility. At the Port of Miami the dredging of the channel to 50’ depth will make Miami only one of three ports on the Eastern Seaboard with this depth which can take advantage of the widening of the Panama Canal. These factors will improve Miami’s international trade as the economy recovers and secure Miami’s future as a major air and sea port.
If you’d like more information about the “Commercial Industrial Association of South Florida” send an e-mail to [email protected] or you can view and download the entire Market Report.
By Tom Dixon
As the Great Recession of 2008-2009 continues, its effects are felt in the commercial real estate market and submarkets of South Florida in the form of increased vacancies, lower rents, reduced income and cash flow to landlords and owners of investment properties. If landlords, owners and their leasing agents are not agile enough or willing to bend, blend and extend existing lease agreements, then we will see this segment of the market go through what has happened in the housing markets. However, no matter what action ownership takes the combination of short term loans coming due, the new rules of higher equity requirements, increased capitalization rates and appraisal values might still tilt the balance downward. But no matter, the mortgage debt side of the equation is a subject of a later newsletter. We will discuss here the ownership side.
What is a landlord and it’s representative to do when approached by a large major tenant with several years remaining on their lease term, to reduce rent and/or give up space back to the landlord? There are various concessions and amendments that can be offered and considered. The main element has to be to save the tenant and keep them from vacating the space and moving to another location. Other questions are: How much space do they occupy? How long have they been a tenant? What is their track record in rent payments? Also are they willing to give the landlord financial records of the past 12 to 18 months and a projection of their income for the next 12 to 18 months? Will their request to give back seriously affect the cash flow of the property? And lastly, what is the future of their business? And most important are they going to survive?
Answers to these questions and the willingness to disclose their present and future financial condition will greatly affect the landlord’s ability to bend, blend and extend. Help can take various forms: rent abatement (free rent) for short periods to give them breathing room, rent deferrals with accrued deferrals repaid at a future date with interest, reduced or eliminated rent escalations to provide “breathing room” for a period, give back of space with or without a future take back, updating of base year for operating expense pass-thru to a current year or eliminate it entirely. More help can take the form of paint and new carpet to “refresh” their space in return for extended lease term, say two or three years remaining extended to five to ten years.
Finally, a rent per square foot reduction and some parking rate concession for a short term (12 to 18 months) can go a long way to help a tenant survive these rough economic times. The key is, will you as the landlord or his representative be able to make the value judgment: “Will the tenant survive?” If you have strong doubts, do not play the bend, blend and extend game. Let the space go vacant and find a tenant to occupy the space at a rate where you as the landlord can survive!
CALL US, WE KNOW HOW TO BEND, BLEND AND EXTEND. WE ALSO KNOW HOW TO SURVIVE!
by Steve Magenheimer
If you live in Florida and own property, you will receive a TRIM (Truth in Millage) notice in the next 4 to 6 weeks. This notice will give you an estimate of the real estate taxes that the property must pay, based on the assessment and millage rate. The assessment is established each year by the County Property Appraiser using mass appraisal techniques. The millage rate is based on funds the city and county government need to operate. The real estate taxes for a property is then calculated by multiplying the assessment – say $100,000 times the millage rate of say 19 mills, which is really 1.9% or .019. This equals a tax of $1,900. I sometimes think that the use of the term millage rate is to confuse the taxpayer. It would be much clearer if it was expressed as a percentage of value.
As a taxpayer, you are only obligated to pay your fair share and the only part of the real estate tax equation which can be appealed is the assessment. With the decline in the market values of both residential and commercial properties from January 2008 to January 2009 the new assessment should be lower of the year of 2009 compared to the year of 2008.
However, because of the continuing need of the government for revenues it is possible that the millage rate will increase for the tax year of 2009. If the assessment for property declines by say 10% and the millage rate increases by 10% the final tax bill and revenues collected by government will be the same.
If you have property which has been enjoying the benefits of homestead exemption, your taxable or homestead exempt value may remain the same but with an increase in the millage rate you will have an increase in your taxes.
The TRIM notice you will receive at the end of August is an estimate of the taxes you will pay based on the government receiving the same amount of revenues in 2009 as in 2008. After you receive the TRIM notice, there is usually a period of 25 days to file an appeal petition if you wish to protest the assessment. Then, sometime in the next 12 months there will be a hearing before a Special Magistrate to protest the assessment.
If you object to the real estate taxes there are two proactive things you can do. One, attend the budget hearing at the City and County Commission meetings and tell government to stop spending so much money. Two, appeal your assessment.
As a property owner, you can file the appeal and present your arguments before the Special Magistrate. However, many property owners have found that using a professional is much more effective. With our 30 plus years of combined knowledge of South Florida real estate valuations as real estate brokers, professional appraiser, teacher and economic analysts, we are well equipped to represent property owners in the successful appeal of real estate tax assessments.
CALL US WE KNOW THE APPEAL PROCESS
Tom Dixon 305-443-4966
After you receive your 2009 assessment visit our Tax Appeal Page and fill out the form at the bottom if you want us to review your assessment.
Last Friday, I attended with 130 other professionals the presentation of the Official 2009 Annual Miami Office Market Report by the Commercial Industrial Association of South Florida, (CIASF). Data for the report was based on information from Black’s Office Guide. The report was prepared and presented by my two able office mates, Tom and Andrew Dixon. There was also a panel of office leasing professionals sharing their views of the office market and presenting estimates for the remainder of 2009 and 2010.
As an office leasing professional in South Florida for over 30 years acting as both a tenant and landlord professional broker representative, to me the glass is always half full. This market for the foreseeable future will be soft and stagnant, with higher vacancies, lower rents and greater concessions by landlords to keep existing tenants and attract new ones, particularly in the Downtown and Brickell Districts.
When the new office buildings hit the market in 2010, the Miami-Dade office market will have a total close to sixty million square feet of rentable space. Where are these tenants going to come from? The CIASF report shows that the number of businesses with more than 100 employees have shrunk to less than 300. Landlord/Developers building high-rise structures with large floor plates will find that users are few and far between for their space. Only larger tenants can efficiently use large floor plans.
The economy of South Florida is based on three structures holding up our communities; tourism, finance/trade and construction. Construction will not be a factor in the near term and tourism does not create a significant office demand. A majority of the office space I have leased is in Coral Gables, home to multi-national tenants based here to service their Latin American businesses. They are not large users of office space. Typically, they will occupy 1,500 to 2,500 SF. Some landlords are aware of this requirement and have tailored their marketing programs in this direction. Other landlords, many on Brickell Avenue and Downtown are still looking for full floor tenants. Most of these will be large regional law firms that continue to see opportunities to locate to Miami/Coral Gables to service their international clients in Latin America.
So, where are we and where are we going, and better yet, how do we get there? First, with few exceptions, new tenants to the market are going to be few and far between. Landlords will have to offer huge concessions to attract them. These will take the form of free rent, moving allowances and generous tenant improvement budgets. A bit of history here, as the landlord’s representative in the Texaco Latin America-West Africa division lease for 72,000 SF in Coral Gables twenty five years ago, the lease provided an 18 month rental abatement on a ten year lease. Plus, turnkey tenant improvements and free parking! The effective rate was in the mid $20’s/SF and the face rate was in the low $30/SF.
Other that new tenants, landlords have to react to existing tenant needs to retain them. Reduced rents, moving base year operating expenses pass-thrus and rent abatement will be the order of the day. Otherwise we will see a massive game of “musical chairs” throughout the market. With tenants moving from one building to the next for lower rents.
We will get “there” by having leasing professionals, landlord and tenant representatives educate and inform landlords on the market conditions that will require them to be receptive, creative and realistic to the current market circumstances. Those that do, will enjoy reasonably full buildings, others will suffer vacancies of up to 50%! Remember, those in the business of office leasing have to believe the glass is half full and will stay that way.
CALL US: WE KNOW HOW TO KEEP THE GLASS HALF FULL
To view the 2009 Office Market Report go to www.dixoncommercialre.com click on 2009 Office Report
By: Steve Magenheimer
THE UNDERWEAR FACTOR
Now that the summer rains have started in South Florida it reminds me that there are cycles to the weather, life, financial markets and it seems everything around us. Three months ago we were commenting about the cool weather and when would it be warm enough to go swimming. Now the water is warm and we wonder will the weather ever become cool again.
As hard as it is to believe the financial struggles we are going through will pass and the clock of financial markets will turn and the economic cycle will go from bad to worse and then start to get better. My explanation for this is the “Underwear Factor.” It could be called the bed-sheet factor, towel -factor or automobile tire factor. Things will need to be replaced and no matter how long we wait to replace them they will eventually wear out.
The wear-out cycle for cars used to be three years, for copiers five years, for computers four years. A good copier salesman would contact an office and ask “how old is the office copier.” If the answer was two years he would set a reminder to contact the office in three years. If the copier was more than five years old he had a good prospect for a new copier.
The result of this natural cycle is that some things are replaced because the technology has changed, other are replaced because they have worn-out and others because fashion and styles have changed. Think about the things you use every day. Eventually, they will need to be replaced. As much as we hold off on buying new things eventually we must. The “we must” starts the cycle over again and goods are produced to meet this demand.
For an example consider the automobile industry. They produced cars with a life cycle of three to five years. At the end of this period the paint failed, the body rusted out and mechanical parts need replacing. Of course, also the styles changed and we all wanted to stay in fashion. The result was a continuing demand for new cars. Then there was a change, car manufacturers started producing better cars than last six-seven or even ten years before they need to be replaced. This reduced the demand for cars by 50% but I guess the manufacturers never figured this out.
Now let’s look at the current economic cycle. Beginning in the summer of 2007 the overbuilt and over financed real estate market began to collapse. This meant that homeowners had less equity to obtain loans, employment declined, consumer spending declined and the “Economic Clock” started to wind down. Hopefully, the “Clock” will start to rewind when the “Underwear Factor” comes into play and consumers will need to buy more goods. The decline in home prices will end and with lower prices more buyers will move into the market. It will be a slow process because of the excesses of the past several years, but it will happen.
How long will it take to rewind the “Clock”? I’m reminded of the statement of my real estate professor in college, “housing is the hand maiden of the GNP.” The real estate and housing market has brought the economy down and it needs to recover before it can bring the economy up.
WE WILL LET YOU KNOW WHAT TIME IT IS ON THE ECONOMIC CLOCK
By Tom Dixon
As an active real estate broker in South Florida the changes I have seen in the market for real estate are both upsetting and beneficial.
The upsetting part began in 2005 and 2006 when money was so plentiful that almost any borrower could qualify for a loan. These borrowers realized that if they could purchase property with 100% financing and the value of the property went up they made an infinite return on their “investment.” In fact, this looked so good that many buyers-speculators purchased multiple properties solely with the intent of reselling them at a profit. This led to groups of individuals buying and selling to themselves at ever increasing prices. Using these systems condominiums appeared to be doubling in value in less than a month. As the prices increased this drew more and more speculators into the market.
How was all this possible? Easy money based on loans without income verifications, credit reports or proof of ability to repay. Some of these loans were called “NINJA” loans (No Income No Job or Assets). Who provided these loans? Mortgage brokers wrote these loans, they were sold to a wholesaler, who sold them to an investment bank. The investment bank packaged them and resold them to investors. Everyone made a profit and hoped that they could resell the loan before the borrower missed a payment. The problems started when the “NINJA” borrower stopped making the payment because he could not flip or resell and did not have the income to make the payment.
Jump to mid-2006, the impact of this speculation and false demand was residential construction and speculative building not seen since the early 1970’s. All of this buying and selling at ever increasing prices created an apparent wealth from real estate ownership.
Housing became so expensive most of the residents in South Florida did not have an income to cover the cost of housing. Of course this also led to higher taxes and insurance premiums because of the apparent increase in values. The chain started to break in mid-2007 when foreclosures increased, construction spending declined and unemployment started to rise.
The beneficial part of this cycle is that the cost of housing has declined and more families should qualify to obtain home loans, real estate tax assessments will decline and insurance premiums should decline because of lower insurable values. As the real estate market stabilizes and the existing inventory is occupied the market will recover. If history is a guide we have had similar real estate booms and busts every 10 years. The first real estate bust I experienced was in the early 1970’s and they repeated on a ten-year cycle.
When all of the new proposed financial stimulus packages are funded I predict a new round of inflation. It may take two to three years but the trillions of dollars being funded by the government will bailout the economy and bring on a new round of inflation. This in turn will help the banks with increases in the safety and the value of real estate loans. This inflation will raise the price of everything including fixed assets such as real estate. My recommendation is that if we have a new round of inflation then the best investment you can make is to buy fixed assets such as real estate with a long-term, low interest rate loan which can be repaid with inflated dollars.
Call us we have been through the Cycles
By Tom Dixon
Last week Andrew and I presented the 2009 Miami-Dade County Industrial Market Study to over 240 members of the Commercial Industrial Association of South Florida. This is 14th year we have reported on the industrial market conditions in South Florida.
The Market Trends Section reported a growth in industrial space for the year of 2007 of just over 2,000,000 SF a decline of about 10% from the prior year. This downward trend was also evident in the industrial employment sector showing an employment decline of 2,500 to a total employment of just over 182,600. For the year of 2008 projected total freight at the Port of Miami declined by 6% while freight through Miami International Airport remained the same.
The Market Activity Section shows a decrease in the volume of warehouse sales from 144 in 2007 to 74 in 2008 and a decline in the average sale price from $85/SF to $71/SF. The industrial condominium market also slowed with a volume of 349 in 2007 to 167 in 2008 and an average price decline from $149/SF to $144/SF.
Because of the variety of warehouse/industrial properties in various locations Miami-Dade County is divided into seven regions based on similar types of properties in each region. All regions are reporting an increase in the amount of rental space available, an increase in the vacancy rate of 2% to 5% and rental rate declines of $2.00 to $4.00/SF.
Summary
If you’d like more information about the “Commercial Industrial Association of South Florida” send an e-mail to [email protected] or you can view and download the entire Market Report on our website www.dixoncommercialre.com
By Tom Dixon
Gary Sisler’s —-Holiday Thoughts
Most of us have experienced seeing real estate recessions and bounce backs…but, this one seems more serious, perplexing and sobering. We would like to think that the savvy pundits would be more evident in hoisting warning flags. It seems to say that we are ill served by the press which has so few trained to write with any meaningful experience with economics.
Globalization—we now learn that our economy is entwined with global influences. Global investors were attracted to our packages of high yield mortgages. Ratings of those packages overvalued their credit strength. Greed on Wall Street is difficult to regulate yet alone monitor.
Politics has not helped prudent real estate investors. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, encouraged by Congress became such an important player Congress could not let it falter. We need to understand that there is a price-penalty to pushing the purchase of houses with scant regard for adequate down-payment and verification of the borrower’s ability to pay.
For the older part of the population this is going to translate into much more conservative spending and investing habits. What does all this mean? Hang on, it certainly looks like 2009 is going to be a wild ride. However, for this Holiday try to forget the negatives as best you can and spend more time with your families. Love for each other should not be affected.
Steve Magenheimer’s— Holiday Thoughts
This holiday newsletter written a week or so before Christmas can be a reflection of the year past (2008) or it can be a projection of what we believe 2009 will bring.
In a year of credit crisis; the largest bank failure in US history (Washington Mutual) and the largest bankruptcy (Lehman Brothers) and a national election that elected the first African-American to become president of the US, it is difficult to predict that 2009 will be a peaceful year. In spite of the recent shoe throwing incident at President Bush, the war in Iraq is virtually over, and the US has a reliable (?) ally in the Middle East to help stabilize the region. Afghanistan will be a challenge for the new administration to say the least.
Most pundits say 2009 will see more of the same failures, foreclosures, bankruptcies, etc. As an individual commercial real estate broker, specializing in office leasing and investment sales, there is little I can do to effect change, beyond staying positive and making the right verbal confessions. But if I continue to do the same things as in the past, and they are no longer working, I am a fool.
So at TMC we look to the New Year with anticipation. Conditions may worsen before they improve; we are not at the bottom yet. It is not important to know when the bottom is reached and the upturn starts, let the experts do that. What is important is how you react to the process and what adaptations you employ to not only survive, but prosper.
God Bless All, Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year. And, when you give thanks this season, bless and ask the Lord to watch over our brave troops in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Tom Dixon’s —Holiday Thoughts
For the past several days Miami has been enjoying cool clear weather which is so different from the rainy, hot weather during the summer. And, just as it is pleasant now I can guarantee that in 6 months it will be summer time and the rain and heat will return. This cycle of weather is natural and we all accept this cycle of change.
Now that we are in the middle of very severe recession I think it is time to look forward and consider what I call the “Clock of Real Estate” but could just as easily be called the “Clock of the Economy.”
The clock starts at noon with an oversupply of real estate..
this leads to increasing vacancies which leads to ….
declining prices which leads to declining construction…
following this will be low vacancies followed by….
increasing prices which encourages …
more construction…
finally we are back again with oversupply…
and the cycle repeats itself.
Change the words from real estate to cars and you see the same pattern. What this tells us is that there is an economic cycle just like there is a cycle to the weather. As hard as it is to believe that it will be hot this summer I can guarantee that it will be hot this summer. By the same token I can assure you that we are going through an economic cycle and sometime in the future we will realize that the hands on the “Clock of the Economy” have moved and we have gone full cycle.
Andrew Dixon’s —Holiday Thoughts
What happened to 2008? It’s seems like just yesterday that people were sleeping on street corners in lines ready to drop down 20% on their third condo unit on South Beach, like they were buying tickets to the concert of the century. Today million dollar CEO’s are sleeping outside Congress waiting for their chance to beg for a loan. It’s been a pretty amazing year as we’ve slid from one end of the economy to the other. Or have we? In some respects I think the general populace is still living in denial of what is happening around us. Perhaps eventually we will accept that not everyone deserves a mortgage, or a new car every 2 years. When the make-believe money that created the credit-crisis gets taken away, which it must, the effects will be brutal, but until then I’m still getting credit card offers every day. The powers that be are seemingly willing to spend every dollar Congress is willing to give them out of your tax pocketbook in order to maintain real estate prices (not values) that were built on smoke and mirrors (fraud and un-sustainable lending practices.) And likely just when we feel the worst is over, and the storm has passed, we’ll all walk outside to realize it was just the eye of the hurricane. Luckily we Floridians are used to this concept. I apologize for the negativity, but I don’t believe the recovery will be nearly as fast as the fall.